Ann,Yah, I know the feeling, Ann. Too many people, deep down, think of all these precious animals as nothing more than 'playthings', objects for their amusement and convenience, and nothing more. They get them to fill a void in themselves, but these types of people don't even know what void they're trying to fill, they're such shallow thinkers/feelers. So they can't even begin to comprehend how wrong they are about animals, nor how deeply the absence of our beloveds affects us. To them, it's just a matter of trading one generic creature for another one who's.....no, strike that, in their minds, THAT (in keeping with their notion that animals are "its"/objects) is some kind of carbon copy of any other. It's pointless even trying to help them understand what these deep and meaningful connections mean. They're too shallow to ever care about what they've been missing out on.
Your potential answer may be a good one to try (and let us know if it actually works!), although I suspect some of these types of people might even come back with some trite remark they think will help bring you back to life in a jiff, like, "Well,
everything dies eventually, and life has to go on!"......as if that's going to make you fall down and kiss their very feet with the sage 'wisdom' spewing out of their ridiculous pie-holes.
As for Piper, it might be that she's (only) living up to the potential of what everyone has thought about her (no matter the initial cause) and can't surpass such entrenched thinking without a little help. I've always practiced a different way of relating to animals that seems to really make a difference in how they ARE with me. I always allow them the opportunity to delightfully surprise me with how smart, wise, quick, loving (fill in the blank with whatever you like) they can be. And when I've forgotten this approach and fallen back into mundane thinking, then, often
instantly upon "changing my mind" about them, they'll rise to the the occasion/chance and make it obvious that
I was the one really holding them back....with my thoughts about them! This isn't to say they'll all be exactly how you want them to be (and that would be pretty selfish of us anyway), but that whatever
potential they have in their earthly personalities and bodies will be given an energetic route to come forth and shine into being. I've proved this theory to myself on many occasions, and it hasn't failed yet, on the whole.
For example, one of my feline girlfriends seemed, upon first impressions, to not be terribly swift in picking up on games I presented to her. This went on for some time until I suddenly remembered again (in grief, I'd forgotten this lesson) that maybe it was MY thoughts limiting her potential. So I changed my mind on the spot, instead thinking & truly believing "You can DO IT! I KNOW you can!" And I kid you not, within one minute of me changing my mind about her, she began not only easily picking up on the game at hand but THEN even started
initiating games that me and my (terribly smart!

) own kidlets used to play! So, in the space of a few short minutes, she was suddenly a whiz at games! And this was the mindset I'd had about my own kids from the start - basically, a "show me what you can do and BE!" atti*tude, and they certainly didn't 'disappoint'! I've done this with quite a few cats, all with good improvements. So far, it's only when I can't get out of my own way, like if I can't get past a fear or something, that it doesn't work. As I've said many times before, they are total MIRRORS of what needs addressing in
ourselves, and they're MASTERS at it.
Plus, on a strictly earthly-based scale, dynamics most often change, and sometimes dramatically, when one family member is no longer around, so give Piper a chance to possibly come into her fullness based on that alone, if nothing else. You could try giving to HER what you'd like to see her become, and see what happens. Despite our already ever-loving relationship since first bloom, Nissa not only came MORE into her own, unique and inherent beingness when her brother left us, but she added much
more than ever before as well. And this became the proverbial Silver Lining of having lost our fur-son at too young an age. If that hadn't happened, and in that order, I likely never would have seen her blossom the exact way she did. And that was also one of the biggest things that got me through Sabin's death and something I absolutely HAD to count as a total blessing.
Jon,You so wisely noted:
QUOTE
Have you EVER met someone who said they hated dogs or cats, who did not eventually reveal defects in personality or character?
Short answer - NO. Longer answer - I just had another experience of this myself. A friend of several decades, who doesn't exactly "hate" cats but is terrified of them, revealed, in
spades, how truly messed up she is on a deep, deep level when we spent, I'll now say, WAY TOO MUCH time with her all at once. To add a form of insult to injury, she also revealed her totally 'shouldy' nature by telling me I "
should" just "put down all of those CAT books" (as if this is something requiring contempt for) and read some work of fiction
she liked, instead & for a change.....as if reading this one, stupid book would rock my world and I'd see the error of my foolish ways of
following my own heart.

Needless to say, she's become another write-off to add to the rapidly growing dung pile.
On the down-side of all this necessary-to-mental-health culling, if my world shrinks any
more, I might just wink right out of existence! There really is no one left to hold me up anymore when times get, or rather,
remain tough, and I still can't find any real point in me being in this world anymore. When you're just not NEEDED by anyone, and no one values what you ARE, what's the point in
anything? Pretty much everybody I'd (willingly, at the time) gone out of my way to help, even when I was so terribly down myself, ended up abandoning me as soon as
I was in need of some care back. I can sit and say they're the real "losers", but at the same time they helped ME feel like one, too, by not being worth their time to support. Their needs always superseded mine, no matter how serious my situation was compared to theirs.
And like Ann, I really only want my own kids back and there's just no arguing with that feeling - and still not even ready for that whole scenario yet, regardless. The only ones who truly value what I have to give are 3 of my feline girlfriends, 2 of whom I rarely even get to see now, and the other being new around here....unless she'll end up helping me more than I can even fathom at this point. My world is just so very empty now. no matter how I try and fill it back up with other pursuits.